Australian Football

AustralianFootball.com Celebrating the history of the great Australian game

 

Melbourne vs Geelong

Scoreboard | Match report | Match statistics

Round: 12   Venue: M.C.G.   Date: Sat, 04-07-1914 3:00 pm   Crowd: 3,568  
Melbourne 1.1.71.1.72.3.153.4.22 C:  Len Incigneri
Geelong 1.5.112.7.196.9.459.14.68 C:  Billy Orchard
  GEEL by 4GEEL by 12GEEL by 30GEEL by 46  

Match Report

A POOR EXHIBITION

SCRAMBLING, CONGESTED PLAY

The small attendance at the Melbourne ground witnessed a dull, uninteresting game between Geelong and Melbourne, far below League form, the kicking especially being poor. The first half was not worthy of either team, and, although the second was somewhat brighter, it was a most unsatisfactory display. At some stages more than half the players were following the ball, and in consequence the game was rarely in the open. What little there was in the way of good football was on the Geelong side. Len Incigneri, the Melbourne captain, was unable to play owing to influenza, and Lilley has not recovered from an injured leg. Evans and Quinn reappeared. Dalton and Slater were away from Geelong and the places were filled by Blencowe and Martini.

1st Quarter

The wind blew across the ground slightly in favour of the east goal. Melbourne had the benefit of it at the start. Geelong were first to attack, and after two behinds had been scored quickly Heinz snapped first goal from the ruck. Healey, with a shot from the wing, hit the post, but half the quarter had gone before Daly dropped the first point far Melbourne. This was followed by a goal which Cannole snapped after a great dash forward by Trahair, McKenzie, and Quinn. Geelong had several shots, which went wide and the quarter ended with the scores:—Geelong, 1 goal 5 behinds; Melbourne, 1 goal 1 behind.

2nd Quarter

The second quarter was a repetition of the first, loose play all over the ground being noticeable, and the ball being kept hovering between the half back and forward lines, neither side being able to get near enough to score for the greater part of the term. Martini being off the field, Geelong were a man short, but Melbourne were not strong enough to take advantage of it. Only one goal was scored, however, by Geelong, Orchard almost at the outset getting it, while Melbourne failed to score. A fine run by Heinz was the only feature of the quarter, and at half time the scores were:—Geelong 2 goals 7 behinds; Melbourne, 1 goal 1 behind.

3rd Quarter

The third quarter saw some improvement in the kicking, and Geelong generally playing a stronger game, especially in the ruck, where Gray, Orchard, and Heinz were doing splendidly. Alec Eason helped Martini to add Geelong’s next goal. Bill Eason got another soon after, and then Melbourne gradually worked forward, and Quinn scored their second goal. Bill Eason snapped fifth goal from the ruck, and Orchard, dashing into goal from half-forward, registered Geelong's sixth. At three-quarter time the scores were:—Geelong 6 goals 9 behinds; Melbourne, 2 goals 3 behinds.

4th Quarter

Geelong were much too good for Melbourne in the final term. The play was a good deal about the centre, however, and Melbourne were rarely able to break through the defence. Heinz snapped the seventh goal for Geelong, and, after some dodging about the forward mark by Alec Eason, Blencowe kicked another. A series of marks between Scown, Orchard, Baker, and Fairbairn ended in Heinz getting the ninth and final goal for Geelong. Best got Melbourne a third goal cleverly, and the game ended with the scores:—

GEELONG, 9 goals 14 behinds, 68 points.
MELBOURNE, 3 goals 4 behinds, 22 points.

For Geelong, Heinz roved in his best form, and he had much assistance from Orchard, who ran and kicked splendidly. Gray put in solid work in the ruck, while McCarter, Grigg, Bill Eason, Johns, and Marsham were all noticeable at times. For Melbourne the most prominent were Cannole, Trahair, Evans, Baquie, Allen, Gunn, McKenzie and Lugton. Winslow had an easy game to umpire, but did not seem to please either side.

FOOTBALL INCIDENTS

Geelong were deprived of the services of Martini during the second quarter of the match on the M.C.C. ground, owing to an accidental knock. Several players made a rush for the ball, and Allen, of Melbourne, got it. Martini, who was just behind, with another Melbourne man close by, was "sandwiched" between the two. He was carried off on a stretcher, and, after receiving attention, was able to take his place after the interval.

Footnotes

Title: A poor exhibition. Scrambling, congested play.
Author: Observer
Publisher: The Argus (Melbourne, Vic: 1848 - 1957)
Date: Monday, 6 July 1914, p.4
Web: http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article10794235

Title: Football incidents
Author: Observer
Publisher: The Argus (Melbourne, Vic: 1848 - 1957)
Date: Monday, 6 July 1914, p.8
Web: http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article10794360

Thanks to Stephen Wade for helping to prepare this report.

Match stats

Melbourne Match Stats Career
# Player K M H D G B HO T FF FA Age Games G
19 Allen, Bill 0 24y 362d 74 26
29 Armstrong, Charlie 0 31y 116d 36 4
35 Baquie, Jack 0 27y 359d 59 24
30 Best, Arthur 1 25y 259d 21 34
24 Collins, Tim 1 24y 192d 7 9
34 Connole, Jack 0 23y 340d 6 5
10 Daly, John 0 23y 203d 2 0
7 Evans, Jack 0 23y 98d 37 0
22 Gray, Alec 0 23y 53d 11 0
15 Hendrie, Bill 0 30y 163d 77 37
17 Lugton, Frank 0 20y 242d 30 1
1 MacDonald, Roy 0 23y 0d 6 0
27 McKenzie, Bill 0 25y 154d 79 5
16 Monk, Bobby 0 28y 255d 121 14
2 Quinn, Billy 1 23y 342d 6 2
18 Smith, Les 0 22y 110d 5 1
8 Trahair, Bert 0 22y 308d 12 7
33 Williamson, Alf 0 20y 271d 17 5
  Rushed   4  
  Totals         3 4         24y 292d 606 174
Geelong Match Stats Career
# Player K M H D G B HO T FF FA Age Games G
7 Armstrong, Les 0 27y 18d 105 0
25 Baker, Jack 0 22y 207d 20 6
29 Blencowe, Jack 1 23y 48d 3 2
9 Brownlees, Rupe 0 26y 69d 64 1
26 Eason, Alec 0 24y 238d 90 50
15 Eason, Bill 2 32y 201d 197 169
2 Fairbairn, Les 0 25y 70d 62 20
20 Gray, Jack 0 28y 321d 42 5
8 Grigg, Dick 0 29y 26d 185 62
18 Healy, Leo 0 23y 257d 56 21
1 Heinz, George 3 22y 269d 80 62
6 James, Les 'Jack' 0 24y 5d 49 12
21 Johns, Alwyn 0 20y 109d 18 4
3 Marsham, Harry 0 23y 350d 78 40
14 Martini, Percy 1 26y 30d 88 221
4 McCarter, Billy 0 25y 254d 30 2
11 Orchard, Billy 2 25y 329d 99 61
28 Scown, Percy 0 30y 356d 116 2
  Rushed   14  
  Totals         9 14         25y 255d 1382 740

Footnotes

* Behinds calculated from the 1965 season on.
+ Score at the end of extra time.