Revisiting the 100 greatest players
Hindsight might be wonderful, but it also can be embarrassing – especially if it is in black and white for all to see.
More than 30 years ago, I was approached by the K.G. Murray Publishing Company to compile and write a magazine-type book on Australian football’s 100 greatest players.
Fortunately for me (in hindsight, of course), I did not have to list the 100 in order of merit but, rather, in chronological order. This meant that the first of my 100 was St Kilda champion Dave McNamara (right), followed by Collingwood goalkicking legend Dick Lee, and so on. The book ended with the greatest players of the then contemporary era – North Melbourne’s Keith Greig and Barry Cable, Hawthorn’s Leigh Matthews and other champions of the 1970s.
All these players would still make my list of the 100 greatest footballers to have played in the VFL/AFL, but many of those I originally listed no longer would make the cut. After all, there have been many champions since this book was published not long after Gough Whitlam was elected Prime Minister in 1975 and Cyclone Tracy devastated Darwin the previous year.
I am not in the slightest embarrassed about my 100 original selections as I gave the project considerable thought and, in fact, agonised over those who would and should not be included. But, with all due respect to many of the original 100, they would not make my cut with a selection of the best 100 to the present day.
This is highlighted by the fact that the player I regard as the best of today’s crop, Gold Coast’s Gary Ablett, was not even a twinkle in father Gary Senior’s eye when I made my original selections. He was not born until May 14, 1984, well after copies of my old book ended up at the back of cupboards.
And, if I was asked today to nominate my best all-time players in order or merit, both Gary Abletts would be in the top half dozen.
It seems unfair, in hindsight (that word again), to list those of my original selections who would not make a current list but, after another bout of considerable thought and even greater anguish, I would “delist” St Kilda’s Bill Mohr, Fitzroy’s Dinny Ryan, Wilfred Smallhorn and Allan Ruthven, North Melbourne and St Kilda’s Les Foote, North’s Jock Spencer and Allen Aylett, Geelong and South Melbourne’s Lindsay White, St Kilda’s Harold Bray and Colin Watson (left), Collingwood’s Neil Mann, Footscray’s Peter Box, Collingwood and Essendon’s Des Tuddenham, Fitzroy, South and North’s John Murphy, Essendon’s Graham Moss, Richmond’s Kevin Sheedy and Francis Bourke, Hawthorn’s Graham Arthur and Don Scott and Carlton’s Geoff Southby.
They would be entitled to be miffed as their records speak for themselves, with Ryan and Box winning Brownlow Medals.
Mohr was a wonderful goalkicker, Foote was especially gifted and the others had rare brilliance, toughness or leadership qualities, with some having all these qualities.
However, the past 30 years of so have thrown up any number of truly outstanding champions, many of whom already have been admitted to the Australian Football Hall of Fame. My newcomers, in no particular order (least of all one based on merit) would be the two Gary Abletts, James Hird, Craig Bradley, Dermott Brereton, Wayne Carey, Tony Lockett, Adam Goodes, Robert Harvey, Simon Madden, Stephen Kernahan, Malcolm Blight, Bernie Quinlan, Michael Tuck, Nathan Buckley, Matthew Lloyd, Chris Judd, Michael Voss, Greg Williams and Jason Dunstall. Wow, that’s more than a few changes to the list.
Let’s look at their individual records:
GARY ABLETT SENIOR
Many rate Ablett the greatest player of all time, but I believe this is one accolade too many as I rate Ted Whitten, Wayne Carey, Bob Skilton and Leigh Matthews ahead of the man Cat fans adored as “Superman”. However, Ablett was a freakish player, brilliant in all aspects of the game. And to think that Hawthorn let him go.
GARY ABLETT JUNIOR
Ablett the Younger is as good as his old man, and he has a Brownlow Medal to show for his brilliance, with perhaps another one or two to come. His current form for Gold Coast has his many fans salivating and few would argue that he is the best player in the current era.
There have been few more graceful footballers than Hird (right), who seemed to drift from one position to another to take control of a match. He had the lightest of touches in the air and was superbly evasive. A Brownlow Medal and a premiership as Essendon captain are just the tips of his performance iceberg.
Bradley might have had his critics, most of who suggested he was a “wide boy” who avoided the crushes, but this is grossly unfair. Bradley was a ball magnet in 375 games with Carlton, and it sometimes is forgotten he played a total of 501 games with the Blues, the Port Adelaide Magpies, South Australia and for Australia in matches against Ireland. A phenomenal record!
There is little doubt Brereton rates among the greatest centre half-forwards of any era as he combined brilliance with aggression and raw courage. The Hawthorn champion had the ability to turn matches off his own boot and played in five Hawk premiership sides. Just one best and fairest award (in 1985) hardly seems adequate considering his worth to the Hawks.
Many would suggest that Wayne Carey IS the greatest. Although I rate him up there in the top half a dozen, I have Ted Whitten, Bob Skilton and Leigh Matthews ahead of him. Nevertheless, Carey’s brilliance at centre half-forward was a once in a generation gift from the gods. Without him, North Melbourne probably would not have won the 1996 and 1999 premierships.
The fact that Lockett kicked more goals (1360 with St Kilda and the Sydney Swans) puts him in a class of his own. Magnificent but moody, he was the epitome of the power forward. A superb mark, he also was quick and clever on the ground and a deadly accurate shot for goal. It is likely his goals record will stand forever.
From being a skinny kid who could not break into the Sydney Swans’ line-up in his first season with the club, Goodes (left) developed into the archetypal modern footballer – tall, quick, mobile and good in the air. Two Brownlow Medals, two premierships and a rating as the best indigenous player in football history makes him a no-brainer for any all-time list of greats in any number of categories.
Harvey might have won two Brownlow Medals but his worth to St Kilda could not be measured in silverware. He won countless possessions over his 383-game career and rates as one of the greatest footballers never to have played in a premiership side. He won St Kilda’s best and fairest four times and won All-Australian honours an incredible eight times.
Has there been a better ruckman/forward? Madden not only won four Essendon best and fairest awards but topped the Bombers’ goalkicking in 1980, 1982 and 1991. He also was runner-up in the 1988 Brownlow Medal count and was third in 1988. Madden also won the Norm Smith Medal in 1885, played in two premiership sides and captained Victoria. What a record!
South Australian Kernahan ranks with the very best centre half-forwards and was an inspirational Carlton skipper. He topped the blues’ goalkicking over an incredible 11 consecutive seasons and won the club best and fairest in 1987, 1989 and 1992, not to mention leading the Blues to the 1987 and 1995 premierships.
Quinlan was not known as “Superboot” for nothing and it now is incredible to think that Footscray allowed him to cross to Fitzroy, with whom he won a Brownlow Medal in 1981. Quinlan could goal from almost any position from 65 metres. His accuracy was phenomenal and a record of 817 goals from 366 games speaks for itself.
Blight (right) not only won a Magarey Medal with Woodville, but also a Brownlow Medal with North Melbourne. One of the game’s greatest all-rounders, Blight could turn a match in minutes and even topped the VFL goalkicking with 103 in 1982. He also played in the Roos’ 1975 and 1977 premiership sides.
Has there ever been a more durable footballer? Tuck played a League-record 426 games for Hawthorn, yet was unhappy when told to retire at the end of the 1991 season. Although he never won a Hawk best and fairest, he was runner-up six times and captained Hawthorn from 1986-91. Coach David Parkin once described him as the best run-on player he had seen.
Few footballers have looked smoother than Nathan Buckley, who rose to super-stardom with Collingwood after starting with the Brisbane Bears. A Brownlow Medal, a club record six best and fairest awards, a Norm Smith Medal but, alas, no premiership medallion. Perhaps he can win one as Collingwood coach.
Lloyd sits seventh on the all-time VFL/AFL goalkicking list with 926 goals from 270 games with Essendon. Although he had his critics, Lloyd was a goalkicking machine who topped the Bombers’ goalkicking an incredible 12 times. A strong mark, a fast lead, clever on the ground and, most important of all, a deadly left-foot shot for goal.
Judd has been a ball magnet with Carlton and, earlier, with West Coast. Two Brownlow Medals, captain of the 2006 Eagle premiership side, a Norm Smith Medal and countless other awards are testament to his all-round brilliance. Just the type of player to inspire teammates.
Voss was inspirational in most of his 289 games with the Brisbane Bears/Lions. He won a club record five best and fairest awards, won a Brownlow Medal and, most important of all, was captain of the Lions’ 2001-03 premiership side. There have been few better leaders in any football era.
It is incredible to think that Williams (left) played just one season with Geelong before becoming a super-star with both the Sydney Swans and Carlton. There have been few better ball-winners and his handpassing was peerless. And, to cap the dual Brownlow Medallist’s career, he played in Carlton’s 1995 premiership side.
Dunstall topped Hawthorn’s goalkicking 12 times, with a season’s best of 145 in 1992. His total of 1254 goals from 269 games puts him behind only Tony Lockett (1360) and Gordon Coventry (1299) in the League’s pantheon of goalkicking greats. Oh, and he also kicked 17 goals (plus five behinds) in a match against Richmond in 1992.
So there it is, and I apologise for overlooking any of your favourites.
The old and the new
Jim's original 100 greatest players (left), as listed - chronologically - in the 1977 K.G. Murray release, and his revised list (right).
|Vic Cumberland (Melb/StK/Sturt)||Vic Cumberland (Melb/StK/Sturt)|
|Dave McNamara (StK)||Dave McNamara (StK)|
|Dick Lee (Coll)||Dick Lee (Coll)|
|Roy Cazaly (StK/SM)||Roy Cazaly (StK/SM)|
|Ivor Warne-Smith (Melb)||Ivor Warne-Smith (Melb)|
|Gordon Coventry (Coll)||Gordon Coventry (Coll)|
|Albert Chadwick (Melb/Haw)||Albert Chadwick (Melb/Haw)|
|Col Watson (StK)*||Syd Coventry (Coll)|
|Syd Coventry (Coll)||Edward 'Carji' Greeves (Geel)|
|Edward 'Carji' Greeves (Geel)||Albert Collier (Coll/Fitz)|
|Albert Collier (Coll/Fitz)||Alan Hopkins (Foots)|
|Alan Hopkins (Foots)||Harold 'Soapy' Vallence (Carl)|
|Harold 'Soapy' Vallence (Carl)||Harry Collier (Coll)|
|Harry Collier (Coll)||Reg Hickey (Geel)|
|Reg Hickey (Geel)||Jack Regan (Coll)|
|Bill Mohr (StK)*||Bob Pratt (SM)|
|Jack Regan (Coll)||Haydn Bunton (Fitz/Sub)|
|Bob Pratt (SM)||Jack Dyer (Rich)|
|Wilfred 'Chicken' Smallhorn (Fitz)*||Norm Ware (Foots)|
|Haydn Bunton (Fitz/Sub)||Dick Reynolds (Ess)|
|Jack Dyer (Rich)||Herb Matthews (SM)|
|Norm Ware (Foots)||Marcus Whelan (Coll)|
|Dick Reynolds (Ess)||Laurie Nash (SM)|
|Herb Matthews (SM)||Jack Mueller (Melb)|
|Marcus Whelan (Coll)||Ron Todd (Coll)|
|Laurie Nash (SM)||Norm Smith (Melb)|
|Jack Mueller (Melb)||Des Fothergill (Coll)|
|Ron Todd (Coll)||Don Cordner (Melb)|
|Norm Smith (Melb)||Lou Richards (Coll)|
|Dinny Ryan (Fitz)*||Bill Hutchison (Ess)|
|Des Fothergill (Coll)||Bill Morris (Rich)|
|Allan Ruthven (Fitz)*||Bert Deacon (Carl)|
|Lindsay White (Geel/SM)*||Dennis Cordner (Melb)|
|Les Foote (NM/StK)*||Ron Clegg (SM)|
|Don Cordner (Melb)||Charlie Sutton (Foots)|
|Lou Richards (Coll)||Roy Wright (Rich)|
|Harold Bray (StK)*||Bob Rose (Coll)|
|Bill Hutchison (Ess)||Bill Stephen (Fitz)|
|Bill Morris (Rich)||Bernie Smith (WAde/Geel)|
|Bert Deacon (Carl)||John Coleman (Ess)|
|Dennis Cordner (Melb)||Thorold Merrett (Coll)|
|Ron Clegg (SM)||Ted Whitten (Foots)|
|Neil Mann (Coll)*||Jack Clarke (Ess)|
|Charlie Sutton (Foots)||Fred Goldsmith (SM)|
|Roy Wright (Rich)||Neil Roberts (StK)|
|Bob Rose (Coll)||John James (Carl)|
|Bill Stephen (Fitz)||Ron Barassi (Melb/Carl)|
|Bernie Smith (WAde/Geel)||Murray Weideman (Coll/WAde)|
|Jock Spencer (NM)*||Brian Dixon (Melb)|
|John Coleman (Ess)||John Peck (Haw)|
|Thorold Merrett (Coll)||Kevin Murray (Fitz/EPer)|
|Ted Whitten (Foots)||Bill Goggin (Geel)|
|Jack Clarke (Ess)||Bob Skilton (SM)|
|Fred Goldsmith (SM)||Laurie Dwyer (NM)|
|Peter Box (Foots)*||John Nicholls (Carl)|
|Allen Aylett (NM)*||Sergio Silvagni (Carl)|
|Neil Roberts (StK)||John Schultz (Foots)|
|John James (Carl)||Ken Fraser (Ess)|
|Ron Barassi (Melb/Carl)||Alistair Lord (Geel)|
|Murray Weideman (Coll/WAde)||Barry Davis (Ess/NM)|
|Brian Dixon (Melb)||Ross Smith (StK/Sub)|
|John Peck (Haw)||David Parkin (Haw)|
|Kevin Murray (Fitz/EPer)||Doug Wade (Geel/NM)|
|Bill Goggin (Geel)||Darrel Baldock (LT/StK)|
|Graham Arthur (Haw)*||Graham 'Polly' Farmer (EPer/Geel/WPer)|
|Bob Skilton (SM)||John Rantall (SM/NM/Fitz)|
|Laurie Dwyer (NM)||Carl Ditterich (Stk/Melb)|
|John Nicholls (Carl)||Ian Stewart (StK/Rich)|
|Sergio Silvagni (Carl)||Kevin Bartlett (Rich)|
|John Schultz (Foots)||Stan Alves (Melb/NM)|
|Ken Fraser (Ess)||Len Thompson (Coll/SM/Fitz)|
|Alistair Lord (Geel)||Peter McKenna (Coll/Carl)|
|Barry Davis (Ess/NM)||Alex Jesaulenko (Carl/StK)|
|Ross Smith (StK/Sub)||Gary Dempsey (Foots/NM)|
|David Parkin (Haw)||Royce Hart (Rich)|
|Doug Wade (Geel/NM)||Peter Hudson (NN/Haw/Glen)|
|Des Tuddenham (Coll/Ess)*||Peter Bedford (SM/Carl)|
|Darrel Baldock (LT/StK)||Leigh Matthews (Haw)|
|Graham 'Polly' Farmer (EPer/Geel/WPer)||Barry Cable (Per/NM/EPer)|
|John Rantall (SM/NM/Fitz)||Keith Greig (NM)|
|Carl Ditterich (Stk/Melb)||Malcolm Blight (WAd/NM)|
|Ian Stewart (StK/Rich)||Bernie Quinlan (Foots/Fitz)|
|Kevin Bartlett (Rich)||Michael Tuck(Haw)|
|Stan Alves (Melb/NM)||Simon Madden (Ess)|
|Len Thompson (Coll/SM/Fitz)||Craig Bradley (PA/Carl)|
|Peter McKenna (Coll/Carl)||Gary Ablett Snr (Haw/Geel)|
|Kevin Sheedy (Rich)*||Dermott Brereton (Haw)|
|Francis Bourke (Rich)*||Stephen Kernahan (Glg/Carl)|
|Alex Jesaulenko (Carl/StK)||Tony Lockett (StK)|
|John Murphy (Fitz/SM/NM)*||Greg Williams (Geel/Syd/Carl)|
|Don Scott (Haw)*||Jason Dunstall (Haw)|
|Gary Dempsey (Foots/NM)||Robert Harvey (StK)|
|Royce Hart (Rich)||Wayne Carey (NM/Adel)|
|Peter Hudson (NN/Haw/Glen)||Nathan Buckley (PA/Bris/Coll)|
|Peter Bedford (SM/Carl)||James Hird (Ess)|
|Leigh Matthews (Haw)||Michael Voss (Bris)|
|Barry Cable (Per/NM/EPer)||Matthew Lloyd (Ess)|
|Keith Greig (NM)||Adam Goodes (Syd)|
|Geoff Southby (Carl)*||Chris Judd (WCo)|
|Graham Moss (Clar/Ess)*||Gary Ablett Jnr|
- Players marked * are those in Main's original "100 greatest" that have now been omitted.