Australian Football

AustralianFootball.com Celebrating the history of the great Australian game

 

Richmond vs Geelong

Scoreboard | Match report | Match statistics

Round: 5   Venue: Punt Road   Date: Sat, 23-05-1914 3:00 pm   Crowd: 9,000  
Richmond 3.8.265.9.396.15.5110.17.77 C:  Charlie Ricketts
Geelong 1.4.103.11.295.15.456.17.53 C:  Billy Orchard
  RICH by 16RICH by 10RICH by 6RICH by 24  

Match Report

RICHMOND'S FIRST VICTORY

GEELONG'S POOR DISPLAY

The attendance at Richmond to see the game between the local team and Geelong numbered about 9,000. It was a dull, uninteresting game, with hardly any life in it, especially in the earlier stages. The kicking generally was poor, especially for goal, while Geelong gave many the impression that they were tired. It was mostly a ruck game, where Richmond were always superior, and, in consequence, Geelong crowded on the ball in endeavouring to stop the grand play of James and other big men. At some stages fully twenty men were hovering around the ball, and spoiling the play. There was some improvement after the interval, and Geelong managed to pull up, but they failed to see it out, and the last 15 minutes was all in favour of Richmond.

There were three changes in each team, the most notable being the reappearance of the Richmond captain, Herbert, and two new men on the Geelong side in Conradi (Hawthorn Juniors) and Collins (East Geelong). Slater was still unable to play, and Allan, who played well in his first game, was not included in the Geelong team.

1st Quarter

Geelong opened with a fine series of exchanges between Marsham, Heinz, Baker, and Martini, the last-named scoring a behind. Hall got two goals quickly for Richmond, both the result of clever snaps from the ruck, the fine play of James helping him considerably. Martini got Geelong's only goal during the quarter. Richmond had a good number of chances, but failed to kick straight. Bettles was a most noticeable man back for Richmond. Martyn added the third goal for Richmond from a free-kick. The short-passing of Geelong was extremely poor, and at quarter-time the scores were—Richmond, 3 goals 8 behinds; Geelong, 1 goal 4 behinds.

2nd Quarter

The second quarter was a repetition of the first. Poor kicking by Geelong lost them much ground, although they gained six points, and had nine shots for goal, while Richmond got past the goal-line on three occasions. The fourth goal for Richmond was the result of grand exchanges between Nolan, Hughes, Mahoney, and Keggin. Shortly after Martyn got another goal, and then Martini, from out of the ruck, kicked two nice goals in succession for Geelong. At half-time the tally was—Richmond, 5 goals 9 behinds; Geelong, 3 goals, 11 behinds.

3rd Quarter

In the third quarter there was some strenuous play about the centre, players bumping a good deal at times, but no one was used unfairly. The kicking for goal was still wretched, however, and there was a succession of eight behinds, most of them for Geelong, before Maybury, from a free kick, got a goal with a long kick from the wing. In the latter part of the term A. Eason and Heinz from the ruck, snapped goals for Geelong, and at the last change a bare goal separated the teams the scores being Richmond 6 goals 15 behinds; Geelong, 5 goals 15 behinds.

4th Quarter

The last quarter commenced with the players on either side massing on the ball, and struggling for an opening. The spectators, for the first time during the match, showed some enthusiasm, and the cheering was general. Not, however, because it was good football, but the scores being close gave some interest to the supporters. For 10 minutes the scores remained unaltered, and then Herbert got a point for Richmond, Struggling on again, the ball was dropped right in front of goal, and it was at this stage that the mistake of an umpire, as mentioned elsewhere, took place. It took all the go out of the Geelong men, and for rest of the game Richmond took command, and three goals were added quickly by Maybury, Martyn, and Hall. Just on time Rankin got Geelong's sixth goal. Richmond's kicking for goal during the final rally was accurate and clever. An unsatisfactory game ended with the scores:—

RICHMOND, 10 goals 17 behinds (77 points).
GEELONG, 6 goals 17 behinds (53 points).

For the winners James was easily the best man on the ground. He played grand football, always fair, and his high marking was perfect. He has not been seen to better advantage than in this game. Some of the Geelong supporters declared that his play alone beat them. Bettles was a fine defender, as also were Thomas and Danks. Farrell in his new position, in the centre, was well placed, Hall and Mahony, the rovers, were splendid help to James, and on the forward lines the marking and kicking of Keggin was excellent. Martyn, Herbert, and Reeves were hard workers.

For Geelong no one stood prominently, the most useful men on the side being A. and W. Eason, Marsham, Healey, Heinz, McCarter, Dalton, and Fairbairn. Elder umpired.

FOOTBALL INCIDENTS

At the opening of the last quarter at Richmond only one goal separated the teams, and a great struggle commenced. Up and down the players battled for fully 11 minutes before either side got near enough to score. Just at this stage, when a goal meant much to either side, an unfortunate error by the umpire gave Richmond credit for a goal which was actually kicked by an opponent. After the game, James, of Richmond, was asked his opinion about the matter and he freely admitted that Alec Eason, of Geelong, had kicked the ball. Eason was asked why he had kicked against his side, and he said he had no option when about ten opponents had him in a tight corner. It is not the first occasion that a mistake of this kind has happened. It may be remembered that about four years ago when South Melbourne and Essendon were playing, Shea, of Essendon, kicked the ball through goal, and six points were awarded to South Melbourne.

Footnotes

Title: Richmond's first victory. Geelong's poor display.
Author: Observer
Publisher: The Argus (Melbourne, Vic: 1848 - 1957)
Date: Monday, 25 May 1914, p.6
Web: http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article7246214

Title: Football incidents.
Author: Observer
Publisher: The Argus (Melbourne, Vic: 1848 - 1957)
Date: Monday, 25 May 1914, p.8
Web: http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article7246493

Thanks to Stephen Wade for helping to prepare this report.

Match stats

Richmond
Match Stats
Career
#
Player
K
M
H
D
G
B
HO
T
FF
FA
Age
Games
G
16 Bettles, Artie 0 23y 59d 4 0
24 Danks, Arthur 0 22y 260d 23 2
9 Farrell, Ted 0 24y 216d 45 4
22 Hall, Clarrie 3 24y 125d 29 35
1 Herbert, Barney 0 25y 92d 70 18
8 Hughes, Frank 'Checker' 0 20y 86d 3 0
15 James, Hughie 0 24y 19d 85 27
18 Keggin, Ted 2 22y 299d 39 54
10 Mahoney, Bill 0 29y 142d 124 58
29 Martyn, Percy 3 23y 12d 26 55
3 Maybury, Percy 2 22y 241d 64 33
14 Moffatt, Dave 0 22y 5d 27 1
17 Morgan, Fred 0 32y 206d 22 2
7 Nolan, Bill 0 25y 261d 5 0
2 Ohlson, Ted 0 27y 220d 90 29
11 Reeves, Syd 0 22y 267d 50 3
28 Thomas, Bill 'Sonna' 0 27y 194d 139 2
5 Thorp, Vic 0 23y 210d 76 6
  Rushed   17  
  Totals         10 17         24y 242d 921 329
Geelong
Match Stats
Career
#
Player
K
M
H
D
G
B
HO
T
FF
FA
Age
Games
G
7 Armstrong, Les 0 26y 341d 98 0
25 Baker, Jack 0 22y 165d 13 5
17 Brownlees, Tom 0 22y 215d 23 44
27 Collins, Basil 0 22y 346d 13 6
16 Conradi, Harold 0 19y 299d 1 0
12 Dalton, Bert 0 22y 274d 46 0
26 Eason, Alec 1 24y 196d 83 50
15 Eason, Bill 0 32y 159d 190 162
2 Fairbairn, Les 0 25y 28d 55 19
8 Grigg, Dick 0 28y 349d 178 62
18 Healy, Leo 0 23y 215d 49 17
1 Heinz, George 1 22y 227d 73 54
3 Marsham, Harry 0 23y 308d 71 39
14 Martini, Percy 3 25y 353d 82 211
4 McCarter, Billy 0 25y 212d 23 1
11 Orchard, Billy 0 25y 287d 94 55
13 Rankin, Bert 1 21y 95d 6 1
23 Wilton, Billy 0 25y 67d 20 8
  Rushed   17  
  Totals         6 17         24y 208d 1118 734

Footnotes

* Behinds calculated from the 1965 season on.
+ Score at the end of extra time.